When a water heater gives out, most people replace it with the same kind, and that's often the right call. Before you decide, it helps to know what the other two options need from your home.
Tank water heaters
A tank heater keeps a store of hot water ready, heated by gas or by electric elements. It costs the least to buy and install, and a like-for-like swap seldom needs changes to the gas line, venting or wiring.
The trade-offs: when the stored hot water runs out, you wait while the tank recovers, and the tank loses some heat while it sits. U.S. Department of Energy figures put a tank's life at 10 to 15 years. Hard water and skipped flushes shorten it.
Tankless water heaters
A tankless unit heats water only when a tap opens, so a long shower won't run it dry. It hangs on the wall and frees up floor space. Energy Department and ENERGY STAR figures put its life at about 20 years.
Sizing decides whether tankless works for you. Each unit delivers a set flow of hot water, measured in gallons per minute, and every shower, dishwasher and washer running at once draws from that flow. A gas unit also needs a large enough gas supply and its own venting, which can add work when you switch from a tank. In hard water it needs descaling, usually once a year.
Heat pump water heaters
A heat pump water heater, often sold as a hybrid, works like a refrigerator in reverse. It pulls heat from the air around it and moves that heat into a tank of water, using much less electricity than a standard electric tank.
It needs room to breathe. ENERGY STAR guidance puts the air space around a unit at roughly 450 to 700 cubic feet, about the size of a small bedroom. Most models also need a 240-volt circuit, a drain for the condensation, and clearance for service. A garage often fits. Check the model's operating range against the hottest days in your garage.
Which one fits your home
- The simplest swap and the lowest upfront cost: a tank of the same type and size.
- You run out of hot water, or you're short on floor space: tankless, sized to the fixtures you run at the same time.
- An electric tank today and a garage with room: a heat pump unit can lower the power bill.
We install and service all three. Call (623) 707-3869 and we'll look at your current setup, the gas or power you have and where the heater sits, then talk through the options with you.
More about our water heater service.
